Quick Answer
A medical-necessity appeal should answer the exact rationale in the denial, not merely restate that treatment is needed. Ask for the plan criteria and records relevant to the decision, connect the patient's documented facts to those criteria, include the treating clinician's explanation, and follow the deadline and submission method printed on the notice.
Official sources: HealthCare.gov appeal rights · U.S. Department of Labor claims procedure
Reviewed against official federal guidance: July 31, 2026 · Who built AppealArmor
Insurance Denial Help
Build the appeal around the insurer's stated rationale, the plan's criteria, the medical record, and the treating clinician's explanation.
Generate Your Medical Necessity Appeal Now — FreeNo account required. Review every generated statement before filing.
Ready to fight your denial? Generate your appeal letter in 5 minutes →
"Medical necessity" is the standard insurers use to determine whether a treatment or service is required to diagnose or treat your condition. When your claim is denied as "not medically necessary," your insurer is saying the service does not meet their internal clinical criteria.
The plan's definition and clinical criteria matter. A useful appeal compares the verified medical record and treating clinician's explanation with the exact reason and criteria used in the denial.
Ask for the policy, clinical criteria, records, and other guidance relevant to the decision. This lets the appeal answer the actual basis for denial instead of guessing.
Common treatments denied for medical necessity include MRIs, CT scans, surgical procedures, physical therapy beyond initial sessions, specialist referrals, prescription medications, mental health treatment, and durable medical equipment.
Official guidance: HealthCare.gov appeal rights and the Department of Labor claims procedure.
Take a photo or upload the PDF. Our AI extracts every detail: insurer name, claim number, denial reason codes, service dates, diagnosis codes, procedure codes, and appeal deadlines. No forms to fill out.
AppealArmor organizes the denial reason, plan criteria, patient-specific records, and applicable source material into an editable draft. Review every statement and citation before filing.
You receive an editable appeal draft and checklist. Confirm the submission address, deadline, attachments, and review route against the denial notice.
Guarantees your right to internal appeal and external independent review. Requires insurers to use evidence-based clinical criteria and to provide you with the specific reason for denial, the clinical guidelines used, and information about how to appeal.
For employer-sponsored plans: requires "full and fair review" of denied claims. Plans must provide specific denial reasons, give you access to your claim file, and allow you to submit additional evidence during the appeal.
Many plans provide an external review after the internal appeal. Eligibility, timing, and the reviewing organization depend on the plan and denial; follow the rights described on the notice.
Most states have additional protections, including independent medical review boards, expedited appeal timelines for urgent cases, and the authority for your state insurance commissioner to investigate patterns of improper denials.
It means the insurer's reviewing physician determined the service does not meet the plan's clinical criteria for your condition. Critically, this reviewer has never examined you and may be applying guidelines that differ from current evidence-based standards. Your treating physician's recommendation is not automatically overridden by this determination, and you have the legal right to challenge it.
Start with the exact denial reason and plan criteria. Include dated findings, prior treatments and outcomes, functional limitations, and a treating-clinician explanation. Use CMS coverage determinations or clinical guidelines only when they actually apply.
Use the deadline in the denial notice. For many employer health plans, the Department of Labor says claimants must receive at least 180 days, but other plan types and review stages can differ.
The ACA (42 USC 300gg-19) guarantees appeal rights for all marketplace and individual plans. ERISA Section 503 governs employer-sponsored plans and requires full and fair review. State insurance laws add protections including independent medical review, timely response requirements, and the right to file complaints with your state insurance commissioner. AppealArmor identifies which laws apply to your specific plan type and state.
Ask the treating clinician to explain the diagnosis, findings, prior treatments and outcomes, why the requested care is appropriate, and the consequences of delay. The letter should address the plan's stated criteria rather than use a generic template.
AI-powered, evidence-based, ready to mail or email. Most denials are never appealed — the ones that are often succeed.
Start My Appeal →